Brock Purdy’s NFL journey has been nothing short of incredible. From “Mr. Irrelevant” as the last pick in the 2022 draft to leading the San Francisco 49ers to a Super Bowl appearance, his rise has captivated fans and analysts alike. But now, the stakes are even higher: Purdy is eligible for a contract extension, and the negotiations could test the 49ers’ resolve- and the broader NFL quarterback market.
Here’s a look at how Purdy’s extension talks spotlight the challenges of paying elite quarterbacks in today’s NFL.
The Money Gap
Brock Purdy has been one of the NFL’s best bargains, earning a base salary of just $1.1 million in 2025. However, with his rookie deal entering its final year, he’s due for a massive raise. Recent deals for quarterbacks like Trevor Lawrence ($55 million annually), Jared Goff ($53 million), and Dak Prescott (a record $60 million per year) have set a high bar.
For Purdy, resetting the market could be a goal, but it won’t be easy. After a stellar start to his career, his 2024 performance dipped. The 49ers missed the playoffs for the first time since 2020, finishing 6-10, and Purdy struggled with injuries, including a right elbow contusion that sidelined him for the season finale. These factors might complicate negotiations.
Recent Big-Money Deals
NFL teams have learned that handing out massive contracts to quarterbacks is a high-stakes gamble. While Prescott’s record-breaking deal highlighted the value of securing a franchise quarterback, other big-money contracts haven’t aged well.
2025 NFL QB market: Top free agents, trade targets, cut candidates, projected landing spots, contracts, more
— Sports Schedule (@schedulesportz) January 2, 2025
https://t.co/9rbObThNNu
Trevor Lawrence, for instance, has struggled in the first year of his $55 million annual contract, with the Jacksonville Jaguars slumping to a 4-12 record. Tua Tagovailoa, another young star, has dealt with concussion issues and lingering hip problems that raise questions about his longevity. Even Prescott’s 2024 season ended early due to hamstring surgery, fueling doubts about the sustainability of such deals.
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral NFL stories via Google! Follow Us
The Cleveland Browns’ fully guaranteed $230 million contract with Deshaun Watson has also sent shockwaves through the league. Since signing, Watson has underperformed, and the Browns have restructured his deal three times, straining their roster flexibility. These cautionary tales could shape how the 49ers approach Purdy’s extension.
Also Read: Are Brock Purdy And Tua Tagovailoa Truly “System QBs”? A Look At Their 2024 Struggles
The 49ers’ Unique Position
San Francisco has a reputation for smart roster-building, and their strategy gives them options. Former Texans executive Jack Easterby noted the team doesn’t need to reset the quarterback market, thanks to their well-rounded roster.
One intriguing alternative could be Sam Darnold. The former 49ers backup is enjoying a Pro Bowl season with the Minnesota Vikings and will be a free agent this offseason. If Purdy’s demands become too steep, San Francisco could consider bringing back Darnold on a more affordable deal.
That said, the 49ers have consistently expressed their commitment to Purdy as their franchise quarterback. But with a projected franchise tag cost of over $40 million in 2026, they’ll need to decide whether to negotiate a long-term deal now or risk paying more later.
Brock Purdy’s Leverage and Options
Despite his recent struggles, Purdy has leverage. Since taking over as the starter in 2022, he’s posted one of the league’s best QBR ratings. This season, he broke an NFL record with 15 games of at least two passing touchdowns and a passer rating of 115 or higher in his first three years. His career-high 377-yard performance in an NFC Championship rematch against the Lions showed he can deliver in big moments.
Daily @PredictStrike Tweet:
— Fifth Quarter (@FifthQuarter) January 1, 2025
Every Tuesday, let's look at how the Prediction Strike NFL QB market is doing by looking at an "index fund" based on some of the top quarterbacks in the NFL!
Use my referral code when you sign up: 7d618f pic.twitter.com/gGvFTec7ir
However, Purdy’s injury history and the team’s mediocre 2024 season could give the 49ers pause. To help the team retain key players, he might need to accept a shorter-term deal or a slightly below-market extension.
What’s Next for Purdy and the Market?
The outcome of Purdy’s extension talks will ripple across the NFL. It could further normalize sky-high quarterback salaries if he secures a deal in the $50 million-per-year range. However, if the 49ers take a more conservative approach, it might signal a shift in how teams handle these negotiations.
For now, Brock Purdy has to weigh his options: push for top dollar, accept a team-friendly deal, or bet on himself with a shorter contract. Either way, his story has already rewritten the narrative for late-round picks- and the 49ers’ next move will be one to watch.
Also Read: What To Expect From Brock Purdy’s New Contract With San Francisco 49ers?
