We’re halfway through the NFL season, and it’s time to break down the most scrutinized position in the league, frankly, all of sports: the quarterback.
Some of the league’s signal-callers are lighting it up, but there are quite a few that are really struggling to find their footing, and a few… well, let’s just say they might be better off watching from the sideline.
Let’s break down every NFL quarterback’s performance through mid-year and grade them on a scale from F to A+.
Who are the top quarterbacks halfway through the 2024 NFL season?
Arizona Cardinals, Kyler Murray: B+
It’s been a mixed bag for the Cardinals this season, but it is hard to deny that Kyler Murray’s giving fans a reason to believe. Arizona’s offense has looked downright electric at times…
Especially when Murray’s on the same page with rookie standout Marvin Harrison Jr.
It hasn’t been consistent, but Arizona has to hope that it will be. If these two can build chemistry on the foundation that is already turning heads across the league, it could be a game-changer.
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral NFL stories via Google! Follow Us
They’re capable of taking the top off defenses, especially with the support of a ground game that’s consistently pounding out over 5 yards a carry, placing them in the league’s top three. Arizona’s record might be hovering around .500, but with the NFC West wide open, they could sneak their way into the playoffs if Murray can keep finding that spark.
Atlanta Falcons, Kirk Cousins: B
Atlanta’s found the missing piece in Kirk Cousins this offseason despite all of the doubters and haters that came flocking to their door…
The fact of the matter is that he’s brought an immediate boost to an offense that had all of the potential to be explosive.
Slowly but surely, Cousins has settled in and is now taking advantage of weapons all over the field and steering this team to the top of the NFC South.
But now, the Falcons are sitting in the driver’s seat in the AFC South and looking primed for a playoff push.
Sure, they’ve had some unpredictable games, but when Cousins gets going, Atlanta’s offense can keep pace with anyone.
Baltimore Ravens, Lamar Jackson: A+
Lamar Jackson’s keeping Baltimore right in the thick of the AFC playoff race, and he’s doing it in his own unstoppable style. After a shaky 0-2 start, the star NFL quarterback kicked things into high gear, rallying the Ravens to five straight wins and reminding everyone why he’s one of the league’s most dynamic players. Baltimore’s offense thrives on his dual-threat abilities, and his leadership is sparking serious momentum.
Buffalo Bills, Josh Allen: A
The Bills are on a roll, and a big part of that comes down to Josh Allen’s newfound discipline. This season, Allen’s put a premium on ball security, throwing only one interception so far and helping Buffalo lead the league in turnover margin. Allen’s not just airing it out—he’s managing games and knowing when to take calculated risks. The result? Buffalo is looking like a complete team, even without Stefon Diggs…
Buffalo is built for a playoff grind. If he keeps this up, the Bills are as dangerous as any team in the league.
Carolina Panthers, Bryce Young: F
Bryce Young’s rookie season was nothing short of brutal, and, well, year two hasn’t been much better. You have got to feel for him—the Panthers are a team with issues at every level, and Young’s taking the brunt of it. From injuries on the O-line to a lack of reliable targets, the rookie NFL quarterback has been left scrambling, and it shows in his performance.
Let’s just hope it doesn’t completely derail his career trajectory.
Chicago Bears, Caleb Williams: C-
It is tough to fairly evaluate Caleb Williams because there are so many questions about Chicago’s coaching and game management, which has continued to derail the Bears in critical moments.
Williams is a promising talent, and with the right pieces around him, he could thrive. But for now, it’s a question of whether he can keep finding consistency in a system that feels shaky.
Cincinnati Bengals, Joe Burrow: B
Joe Burrow and the Bengals are back to their slow-start ways, and this time, the clock’s ticking on their season. Burrow’s connection with his top targets has been sporadic, but it looks like they may be starting to turn the page.
Burrow has the talent, no question, but Cincinnati’s playoff hopes are slipping fast if they can’t find some cohesion on both sides of the ball.
Also Read: Grading All 32 NFL Teams Starting Quarterbacks After Week 9 Games Of The 2024 Season
Cleveland Browns, Jameis Winston: C-
Jameis Winston’s Browns debut brought a surprising upset over the Ravens, but that’s about the only bright spot in a rough season so far. But his follow-up performance left much to be desired. At 2-7, it is safe to say that the Browns season is over—so this is all about Winston putting tape out for GMs heading into next year.
Dallas Cowboys, Dak Prescott: C-
Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb are putting up impressive stats, but the Cowboys can’t seem to turn numbers into victories. Dallas is struggling to keep pace in a tough NFC East, and now that Prescott’s health is in jeopardy, who knows what this year will turn into.
Denver Broncos, Bo Nix: C-
Rookie QB Bo Nix is getting thrown into the fire, but he’s starting to show some resilience. What’s all the more promising for the Broncos is that while Nix is developing, the Broncos are starting to inch closer to playoff territory, albeit via the Wild Card, as they aren’t about to dethrone the Chiefs.
Detroit Lions, Jared Goff: A+
The Lions are firing on all cylinders, with Jared Goff putting up MVP-caliber numbers, thanks to his accuracy and decision-making, both of which have ascended to new heights.
Green Bay Packers, Jordan Love: B-
Jordan Love has had his ups and downs, dealing with injuries along the way, but Green Bay’s young core has stepped up, including his backup, Malik Willis, who helped the Packers tread water in a tight NFC North race.
Houston Texans, C.J. Stroud: C+
The Texans season has been way more of a ground than most expected, and C.J. Stroud is taking his share of lumps. The sophomore NFL quarterback has shown resilience, taking hits behind a shaky line and still finding ways to make plays, but this is a far cry from what we expected.
Indianapolis Colts, Joe Flacco: C
With Anthony Richardson out, the Colts are leaning on Joe Flacco to keep things moving in the right direction for Indy. They’ve managed to grind out a couple of wins, but with the way he played in his first official game after Richardson’s benching, this team’s future is anything but certain.
Jacksonville Jaguars, Trevor Lawrence: D
It’s been a letdown of a season for Trevor Lawrence and the Jaguars. Expectations were high, but the Jaguars have stumbled, especially on offense, which has been wildly inconsistent this year.
Kansas City Chiefs, Patrick Mahomes: A+
The Chiefs are doing what the Chiefs do best—winning, and Mahomes is right at the heart of it. Sure, the superstar NFL quarterback has thrown a few more interceptions this season, but his ability to adapt and keep Kansas City in control is unmatched.
Las Vegas Raiders, Gardner Minshew: F
The Raiders season has been a struggle for all involved, but perhaps none more than Gardner Minshew, who has played so poorly that he is at risk of losing his starting job to Desmond Ridder, of all people.
Los Angeles Chargers, Justin Herbert: A-
Justin Herbert is doing everything he can with limited weapons on offense, and the system is actually starting to take form in Los Angeles.
Los Angeles Rams, Matthew Stafford: B+
Despite a season that started with a string of injuries, Matthew Stafford and the Rams are somehow staying alive in the NFC West. With Puka Nacua and Cooper Kupp back, Stafford finally has the tools to push this team forward.
Miami Dolphins, Tua Tagovailoa: C
Availability is the best ability, and Tua has really lacked that this year. Obviously, there are bigger concerns than football in his case, but he really needs to step it up if he wants to get this Dolphins team back on track.
Minnesota Vikings, Sam Darnold: B
Sam Darnold’s resurgence in Minnesota has been one of the surprises of the season. He’s playing some of the best football of his career, and the Vikings are reaping the benefits, which they badly need in a highly competitive NFC North.
New England Patriots, Drake Maye: C+
It’s been a rebuilding year in New England, but rookie Drake Maye is starting to show some of the potential that inspired the Pats to take him in the first round.
Maye’s raw, and he’s making rookie mistakes, but he’s got ability. This season is all about building for the future, and Maye’s giving Patriots fans something to look forward to.
New Orleans Saints, Derek Carr: C-
The Saints came out of the gates extremely hot but have fallen equally hard since. Carr’s been dealing with injuries, but still, it hasn’t been great by any measure.
New York Giants, Daniel Jones: D-
The Giants offense has been a train wreck, struggling to even sniff the end zone with Daniel Jones under center—and their embattled QB has already been benched once as Coach Brian Daboll searches for any kind of spark.
New York Jets, Aaron Rodgers: D
The Jets had sky-high hopes coming into the season now that Aaron Rodgers was finally supposed to be healthy and starting for them on a weekly basis, but it’s been nothing more than disappointment after disappointment.
Though the win against Houston in Week 9 showed some promise, the fact of the matter is that Rodgers’s reunion with Davante Adams and this team as a whole hasn’t panned out, and despite a roster packed with talent, because the Jets can’t seem to get on the same page.
Philadelphia Eagles, Jalen Hurts: A-
Jalen Hurts has the Eagles flying high, as he has managed to rediscover the form that led the Eagles to the Super Bowl a couple of years back.
After a slow start to the year, they are beginning to prove that they are the NFC’s most balanced teams. Hurts is taking command of the offense, carving up defenses with his arms, and battering them with his legs… Which has also opened up a plethora of opportunities for the Birds new sportscar, Saquon Barkley, churning out 100-yard games, making Philly’s ground game is one of the league’s best.
Pittsburgh Steelers, Russell Wilson: B+
Russell Wilson has brought new energy to the offense with his ability to stretch the field by going too deep to George Pickens, and while it’s still a work in progress, Pittsburgh is in a good spot in the AFC North.
If they can get the offense to continue to build on the foundation that they’ve laid since Wilson took over for Fields, the Steelers might just be a legitimate playoff contender.
San Francisco 49ers, Brock Purdy: C+
The 49ers came into this season with high expectations after last year’s strong showing, but things have been a bit shaky for Brock Purdy and company.
Purdy’s been thrust into a leading role, and while he’s proved that he has all of the tools to get the job done on a regular basis, the unfortunate reality is that the consistency hasn’t quite been there.
Part of the struggle stems from a rash of injuries that have left key offensive pieces and playmakers on the sidelines. Without his full arsenal of weapons, the star quarterback’s ability to orchestrate the offense has taken a hit, and his production has become uneven, mirroring his NFL team’s performance overall.
Right now, it’s all about getting back to basics, staying healthy, and seeing if Purdy can settle into the consistent force San Francisco’s been hoping for.
Seattle Seahawks, Geno Smith: C+
Geno Smith is leading the league in passing yards, but turnovers are haunting him and the Seahawks. Especially the ones at critical times in the game.
In his defense, we all know that the offensive line has been shaky, and it’s making it tough for Seattle to secure wins in a league where the margin for victory is regularly extremely thin.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Baker Mayfield: B-
Baker Mayfield has been one of the unexpected bright spots for the Buccaneers over the past couple of seasons, injecting the offense with a level of grit and energy they’ve been missing.
Mayfield arrived in Tampa with something to prove, and he’s playing with a chip on his shoulder, putting up numbers and he is keeping the Bucs competitive in the two-horse race in the NFC South.
Beyond his play on the field, his leadership has been evident, not just in the locker room but on the field, as he’s racked up 27 touchdowns and has shown the resilience to hang tough in close games, even when the odds are stacked against him.
Unfortunately, losing a weapon like Mike Evans—a deep threat who can outmuscle defenders and stretch the field and Chris Godwin to boot—has forced Mayfield to lean on the rest of his receiving corps, which isn’t quite as deep as Tampa would like.
Tennessee Titans, Will Levis: F
It’s been a painful season for the Titans, and rookie Will Levis is bearing the brunt of it. Turnovers were piling up, and without a reliable run game, the offense completely stalled out under his guidance.
The only thing in his defense is that injuries haven’t helped, but Levis really found it tough to adjust.
The Titans have since turned to Mason Rudolph as Levis nurses a shoulder injury, which obviously isn’t a long-term solution… but the problem is there’s no quick fix here either—as Tennessee is in full-on survival mode.
Washington Commanders, Jayden Daniels: A-
The Commanders have hit gold with rookie NFL quarterback Jayden Daniels, who’s electrifying fans with his dual-threat abilities. They’re averaging over 30 points per game for the first time in decades, and Daniels has shown he can come up big in crunch time, like in their Monday Night Football thriller against the Bengals.
