Every time we talk about the New York Mets’ offseason plans, Pete Alonso pops up. The MLB is already heating up as it moves to the next leg. With free agency in full swing and the list of available first-base options shrinking fast, the idea of Alonso re-signing with the Mets is looking more promising than ever. Let’s break down why bringing him back could make sense for the Mets for a competitive 2025 season.
First off, the landscape of first basemen in free agency is getting pretty limited. Some big-name players like Paul Goldschmidt and Christian Walker have already signed. And now most of the teams are left with fewer attractive options out there. This situation puts Alonso right in the spotlight for teams looking to fill the first-base role. There’s no denying the fact that he had some ups and downs in his performance last season.
Alonso is undeniably one of the most potent right-handed hitters in the game today. Even if he didn’t always hit the mark last season, pairing him with stars like Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor could be a good idea.
What a Christmas gift it would be if Pete Alonso re signed with the Mets pic.twitter.com/4E4C7oAbTv
— NYM_News (@NYM_News) December 24, 2024
But that’s not a one-take solution. Teams are still exploring options to take Alonso’s services, and that could lead to the Mets getting into a bargaining position. The Yankees have already made their move by signing Goldschmidt, which essentially rules them out of the Alonso sweepstakes. That gives the Mets a distinct advantage in negotiations since they won’t have to battle against their crosstown rivals.
The Texas Rangers recently traded Nathaniel Lowe, leaving them as a potential suitor, but it’s unclear how much they want Alonso at this point. The Cardinals, having lost Goldschmidt to the Yankees, could also be eyeing him. However, their specific needs may not fully align, which leaves the Mets as a very appealing option for Alonso.
New York Mets Is The Best Suitor For Pete Alonso
If we zoom out a little bit, keeping Alonso in New York aligns perfectly with the Mets’ goal of building a contending roster. The organization is heavily invested in making a big impact, and there’s a strong push to maintain competitiveness. Securing a reliable bat at first base is crucial for the offensive structure of the team.
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral MLB stories via Google! Follow Us
If Alonso were to sign elsewhere, the Mets would quickly find themselves in a tricky spot, scrambling to fill a key position at a critical moment. This could lead to hasty decisions that might not serve their long-term interests well.
“Now the Mets are interesting because the entire industry believes they’re going to re-sign Pete Alonso, but if you’re the Mets and you’re going to commit that kind of money – whatever the number comes out to be with Alonso – maybe you’d rather pay Alex Bregman and then move Vientos to first,” Ken Rosenthal said on Far Teritorry podcast.
Ken Rosenthal:
— Metsmerized Online (@Metsmerized) December 23, 2024
“The entire industry believes (the Mets) are going to re-sign Pete Alonso.”
pic.twitter.com/1WzPRbohUK
The dynamics of free agency don’t just revolve around Alonso. There’s a buzz around other infield targets like Alex Bregman. Many are speculating whether the Mets might consider signing Bregman instead. They could end up moving prospects to first base, which might not be the most efficient use of resources. In this light, re-signing Alonso seems like a simpler yet equally effective solution.
Also Read: Former NL MVP Andrew McCutchen Returns To The Pittsburgh Pirates On A One-Year, $5 Million Deal
